Moen 2510 vs 2520 Comparison – Which Shower Valve Should You Buy

Moen 2510 vs 2520 Comparison – Which Shower Valve Should You Buy

1 Brands Research
2 Products Compared
58 Customer Research

QP Review is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

If you are reading this article, it means either your shower valve is acting berserk; or you are on full mode research to find out which one best works for your bathroom.

Moen is such a brand that truly understands the value of shower valves. But now that you have come this far, we understand your frustration in choosing between two incredible products by the brand manufacturer. 

Leave the debate to us. Simply sit back and enjoy the battle of Moen 2510 vs 2520 while sipping your coffee.

By the time you finish reading our argumentative discussion, you will happily figure out what you need!

Moen Shower Valve

Shower equipment you should check

Moen 2510 vs 2520 Comparison – At A Glance

Name Moen 2510 Shower Valve Moen 2520 Shower Valve
Image
Compatibility All Moen All Moen
Construction Brass construction Brass construction
Price Check Price Check Price
Features
  • Size: 0.5
  • Color: Unfinished
  • Material: Metal
  • Number of Ports: Four
  • Construction : Brass construction
  • Connection Size: 1/2-inch IPS connections

How Is Moen 2510 Shower Valve

In this Moen 2510 review, you will know why it is one of the most demanded in the market. It has a design that is easy to install, thanks to Moen’s M-PACT valve system. 

You can practically fit it to any alterations without replacing your plumbing arrangement in the future. People who have difficulty in taking cold showers or when the sudden hot water scalds the skin who would not have a bad day anyway? 

Either it is for you or someone elderly, the 2510 model is packed with beautiful features to maintain the water motion’s peaceful act. 

This model comes with PosiTemp tech, a skill that will maintain water flow decently as well as the temperature. It has 4-port that allows presetting of the hottest temperature before installing.  

And the brass structure will ensure longevity no matter where you fit it; it will not even interfere with the current plumbing situation. 

The unit performs outstandingly under the water and temperature pressure by balancing both according to the setting. 

This is why most prefer Moen 2510 as an-easy going shower valve for their bathrooms. It has a 1222 cartridge that has no problem with back-to-back installation either. 

Moreover, the innovative design also accepts ½ inches of IPS connection type that goes with most standard plumbing.

Moen 2510 Pros & Cons

Below are some positive and negative points about the unit to better understand the features.

Pros
  • Lasts long
  • Compatible with 1/2" IPS connection
  • Works with old plumbing system as well
  • Durable brass construction and heat-resistant brass design
  • Consistent water temperature and excellent regulation of water pressure
Cons
  • A large figure in comparison
  • Difficulty fitting behind the wall
Features
  • Size: 0.5
  • Color: Unfinished
  • Material: Metal
  • Number of Ports: Four
  • Construction : Brass construction
  • Connection Size: 1/2-inch IPS connections

How is Moen 2520 Shower Valve

Why should you choose the 2520 model? Well, let us find out in this moen 2520 review without any delay. 

It is another M-PACT series model from Moen that is equipped with PosiTemp pressure. Controlling the water temperature is far more straightforward with this unit. 

So, people suffering from terrible water flow and unbalanced temperature pressure can breathe a sigh of relief once this model is installed. The common valve system enables the person to set it up like any other standard shower valves. 

This unit has the ½-inch CC valve that comes with a trim style you can upgrade whenever you are renovating your bathroom plumbing system. No valve replacement or additional equipment is necessary for the process. 

It gives the best result when used for tub and shower applications. You can experience the perfect equilibrium of hot and cold water supply, eliminating shower shocks.  

Plus, the stylish brass construction of reliable quality makes it ideal for bath hardware for a new home. It comes with a 4-port design with a single handle.

Forget about scalding in the shower; enjoy the wonderful flow of water, giving you the improved version of the bathing experience you have longed for days. 

Our only advice is to read and understand the instruction guide thoroughly before implementing the setup yourself.  

Moen 2520 Pros & Cons

What’s the better way to comprehend the characteristics of a model than going over the pros and cons segments?  

Pros
  • Sturdy and robust design
  • Enables accurate water flow
  • Forged from brass for longevity
  • Compatible with 1/2" CC connection
  • Best for shower and tub renovation project
  • Excellent water temperature balance and adjustable temperature
Cons
  • Unclear installation guide
  • The valve handle sticks out too far

What is the Difference Between Moen 2510 and 2520 Shower Valve

What sets these units apart from each other? Below is a brief description to show Moen 2510 vs 2520 shower valve comparison to help you choose wisely.

Installation

The biggest hassle with installing 2520 is that the manual guide is vague. So, unless you are an expert at installing shower valves, we ask you to refrain from doing it yourself. 

We did not find such difficulties with the 2510 installation process, but again the problematic instruction guide was in the way of precise positioning of setting up the unit. 

Most have remarked upon the 2510 unit’s straightforward design to understand the fitting navigation promptly. That means even a novice can follow up with the procedure to continue installation without any slip-up. 

Connection Type

This is where the real difference can be distinguished. It is because the 2510 model has ½-inch male connections in a threaded format. As a result, the connection should be tightened to a certain degree to avoid substantial pressure. 

You will have to seal the thread with tape before moving to the next procedure. This will prevent the valve from leaking water when in use with full force. 

The 2520 unit model, on the other hand, comes in ½-inch sweat-to-sweat connections. Thus, you are going to need a soldering kit. 

It means you should be able to obtain specific tools like appropriate solder for copper plumbing, a torch to melt the solder, flux to make the solder flow correctly, and fitting brush to prime the insides of the copper fittings. 

So, 2520 might require more attention than 2510. In any case, they both serve impressively despite the distinction of assembling type. 

Convenience

While both models are forged with brass for solid durability, some slight changes were discovered after/during installing. 

For instance, 2510 has a bulky design compared to 2520, which should be taken under consideration before fitting. The rotating lever function works great on both parts but more effective on the 2520 model. 

2520 does not have male threaded ends, while the latter model does. Even though it is mentioned that both are compatible with shower and tub use, unit 2520 seems well-suited for the purpose rather than the 2510 shower valve. 

2510 can be applied in the kitchen plumbing, too, making it more versatile. However, it is better to mount 2520 in the bathroom only. 

Aside from these differences, the consistency of water temperature and both models’ flow remain the same. 

Comparison Table

Name Moen 2510 Shower Valve Moen 2520 Shower Valve
Size 0.5 0.5
Number of Ports Four Four
Connection 1/2-inch IPS connections 1/2-inch IPS connections
Construction Brass construction Brass construction
Includes Replacement Parts, Bath Faucets And Accessories Valve
Compatibility M-PACT common valve system M-PACT common valve system
Material Metal Metal
Price Check Price Check Price

FAQ's

Q: What does Moen PosiTemp mean?

Ans: It is a temperature-sensitive design that averts getting scalded or unforeseen ice-cold water blast when taking a shower. The system is an important feature to protect adults and children from getting injured or shocks.

Q: How do I know if the Moen cartridge is bad?

Ans: If you experience leakage from different areas even after turning off, then it must be checked. Other symptoms include the inability to receive too hot or too cold water, difficulty turning, opening, closing the shower valve, etc.

Q: How long does a Moen cartridge last?

Ans: It will last about 20 to 30 years at most, which is a great deal considering its steep price.

Q: Can I control the volume and temperature of either unit?

Ans: Moen 2510 and 2520 have only one handle to control the water temperature; a simple lever rotation will do the trick. These valves, nevertheless, lack volume control.

Q: Are all Moen shower valves the same?

Ans: No. The brand has manufactured three kinds of valves so far. They are known as Standard, PosiTemp, and Moentrol. All of them might look quite similar, but the trim is not interchangeable.

Conclusion

It is an understandable situation where one can easily feel frustrated with almost identical two units. However, our article has pointed out that Moen 2510 vs 2520 comparison is possible. 

Hopefully, things will look up much clearer this way to select the right unit for your benefit.

10/10 Total Score
Moen 2510 Shower Valve -